Article:
9/11 Psychology: Just How Resilient Were We?
Thursday, Sept. 08, 2011
Kinogsberg reflected on the psychological aftermath of 9/11. In 2001, psychologists didn’t know how to help survivors; terrorist attacks of that magnitude had never occurred before. An international committee of psychologists was organized to form a comprehensive coping plan, but failed without preceding research off which to base their plan. Konigsberg wrote that 9/11 provided valuable data on how to help in a future attack. He concluded that the best method is to provide basic necessities before assessing psychological trauma and need for professional help.
The context (the 10th anniversary of the attacks) made the story more relevant; this week, 9/11 is at the front of people’s minds more than any other time of the year, and so this context helps the story be more widely read. This piece was written to reflect on how the psychologies community tried to help survivors cope. Another minor aim was to lead readers to other Time articles about 9/11 with links to other Time pages after several of the paragraphs. The author was successful in informing the public of one way the community tried to help victims, but unsuccessful in drawing me to the other pages advertised by the article. Being written for Time Magazine, the audience was the public, perhaps particularly people interested in psychology.
Rhetorical Elements:
- logos
- facts made the writing logical rather than mournful with personal stories (pathos)
- ethos
- prevented the reader from being critical in the relatively-failed international meeting held after the attacks
I think it was interesting how the article talks about how psychologists "didn't know how to help the survivors." I think it is something that people like me (outsiders that were not directly affected by the situation) tend to overlook. We don't understand the true aftermath that 9/11 left on people. It is similar to someone who has never had serious problems at home trying to give advice to someone who might be going through family issues.
ReplyDelete